The Big Question for Homeowners
Few decisions impact your home’s comfort, value, and budget as much as the roof over your head. In Middle Tennessee, homeowners often ask: Should I stick with asphalt shingles or upgrade to metal? Both have strong selling points — but the right choice depends on your long-term goals, budget, and how long you plan to stay in your home. Let’s break it down.
Asphalt Shingles: The Reliable Standard
Asphalt shingles remain the most popular roofing material in America for a reason: they’re affordable, widely available, and deliver dependable performance.
Advantages:
- Affordable upfront cost: Asphalt is usually the lowest-cost option per square foot.
- Variety of styles: Dozens of colors and profiles can complement any home style.
- Simpler repairs: Damaged shingles can often be replaced individually.
- Widespread availability: Every supplier carries them, so replacements are never hard to source.
Limitations:
- Shorter lifespan: Typically 15–25 years, depending on grade and ventilation.
- Storm vulnerability: Shingles can blow off or crack in high winds and hail.
- Heat absorption: Dark shingles can trap heat, raising cooling costs in summer.
Pro Tip: If you choose asphalt, invest in architectural (dimensional) shingles over 3-tab. They’re heavier, more durable, and add curb appeal.
Metal Roofing: The Premium Upgrade
Metal roofing has gained momentum in the Southeast, especially for homeowners planning to stay long-term. While the upfront cost is higher, the longevity and performance can be unmatched.
Advantages:
- Exceptional lifespan: Many systems last 40–70 years.
- Durability: Resistant to wind, hail, and fire — often with Class A ratings.
- Energy efficiency: Reflective coatings can lower summer cooling bills.
- Sustainability: Often made from recycled materials and fully recyclable at end of life.
- Low maintenance: No curling, cracking, or granule loss.
Limitations:
- Higher upfront cost: Metal can cost 2–3x more than asphalt shingles.
- Noise factor: Rain or hail can be louder, though proper decking and insulation reduce this.
- Complex installation: Requires experienced installers; improper work can cause leaks.
- Denting: Large hail can cause cosmetic dents, even if the roof remains watertight.
Cost Comparison in Middle Tennessee
- Asphalt Shingles: $4–$6 per square foot installed.
- Metal Roofing: $8–$12 per square foot installed.
While asphalt is easier on the wallet up front, metal may save you money long-term by avoiding multiple replacements, lowering utility bills, and potentially reducing insurance premiums.
Which Roof Fits Your Lifestyle?
- Short-term homeowners: If you plan to sell within 10–12 years, asphalt may be the smart move. Buyers see a “new roof” and you avoid over-investing.
- Forever homes: If this is your last house, metal may pay for itself through decades of durability and energy savings.
- Storm-conscious families: Metal’s wind and hail resistance can mean fewer headaches after severe weather.
Middle Tennessee Climate Considerations
Our region faces humid summers, storm seasons, and occasional snow. Here’s how each roof type handles it:
- Asphalt: Performs reliably but ages faster under heat and UV exposure.
- Metal: Reflects heat, sheds snow, and resists high winds — making it a strong option for unpredictable weather.
The Bottom Line
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Asphalt shingles offer proven value and flexibility, while metal roofs provide unmatched longevity and strength. The right choice comes down to balancing your budget, long-term plans, and tolerance for future maintenance.
Final Thoughts
Your roof is not just a cover — it’s your home’s first line of defense, a major curb appeal factor, and one of the largest investments you’ll make. Whether you go with asphalt or metal, the key is professional installation and proper ventilation.
At Hoots Roofing, we don’t just install a product — we help homeowners weigh the real costs, pros, and tradeoffs. With clear information and expert craftsmanship, we make sure you choose a roof that fits your home, your lifestyle, and your future.
Ready to Compare Options?
👉 Schedule a Free Roof Consultation
📞 Call us today at (931) 221-2115 to discuss what roof makes the most sense for your home.